HP 67 vs 67XL: Which Ink Cartridge Should You Buy?
Shopping for ink for your HP DeskJet and stuck between the HP 67 and HP 67XL? They're the same ink in different-sized tanks — but which one you should buy depends entirely on how much you print. Here's the honest breakdown.
boltQuick Answer
The HP 67XL is the same ink as the HP 67, just more of it — roughly double the pages (about 240 black pages vs about 120). If you print regularly, the 67XL costs less per page and you replace cartridges half as often. If you print only occasionally, buy the standard 67: ink can dry out in a rarely-used printer, and a half-dried XL is money wasted.
HP 67 vs 67XL: The Real Differences
The only real difference: ink volume
| HP 67 (Standard) | HP 67XL (High Yield) | |
|---|---|---|
| Black page yield | ~120 pages | ~240 pages |
| Tri-color page yield | ~100 pages | ~200 pages |
| Best for | Occasional printing | Regular printing |
| Upfront cost | Lower | Higher |
| Cost per page | Higher | Lower |
| Same printers? | Yes — interchangeable | Yes — interchangeable |
Yields are HP’s stated approximate figures; real-world results vary with what you print.
There's no quality difference. Same ink formulation, same printhead technology, same colors. The XL cartridge is physically the same size — it just contains more ink. Think of it as buying the large coffee instead of the regular: same coffee, better per-cup price.
Cost per page: where the XL wins
This is the math that matters. The 67XL typically costs about 40–50% more upfront but prints roughly twice as many pages. That works out to a meaningfully lower cost per page — usually 25–35% cheaper per page than the standard 67. If you print even a few pages a week, the XL pays for itself quickly. Heavy printers (home office, schoolwork, photo printing) should always buy XL.
Which One Should You Buy?
Print weekly or more? Buy the 67XL
Lower cost per page and half as many cartridge swaps. The math is simple — regular printers always win with XL.
Print only occasionally? Buy the standard 67
Inkjet ink dries out. If months pass between prints, a half-used XL can clog or dry before you finish it — and then the “cheaper per page” math collapses. The 67 also costs less out of pocket.
HP+ printer? Buy genuine HP only
On HP+ printers (like the DeskJet 2755e), the printer may reject non-HP cartridges or nag you constantly — HP+ requires original HP cartridges to function. Whichever size fits your volume, buy genuine for these models.
Compatibility
Both cartridges fit the same printers — they're fully interchangeable. Common models: HP DeskJet 2700 series (2700e, 2722e, 2755e, 2734e…), DeskJet 4100 series, DeskJet Plus 4100 series, and ENVY 6000 series. If your printer takes the 67, it takes the 67XL.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between HP 67 and 67XL?expand_more
Is HP 67XL worth the extra money?expand_more
Can I use 67XL instead of 67?expand_more
How many pages does HP 67XL print?expand_more
Do remanufactured 67 cartridges work?expand_more
Which printers use HP 67 ink?expand_more
Where to Buy
HP 67 ink on Amazon · HP 67XL high-yield on Amazon
Related: How to fix printer streaks · Not printing black? 7 fixes